Second Nature by Jacquelyn Mitchard

From the Hardcover editionSecond Nature by Jacquelyn Mitchard
Published by Random House
Review copy provided by the publisher

When Sicily Coyne was thirteen years old, she and her firefighter father were in a fire at her school, a fire that killed her father and left her with a disfigured face. Sicily’s mother passed away two years later, so Sicily was raised by an aunt who taught her to live life to the fullest, and as an adult Sicily is happy, engaged to a wonderful man who she’s known since childhood. But when she learns a devastating secret that shatters her entire life, she decides to take a huge plunge and accept the face transplant surgery that is being offered to her. The surgery changes her life in a million ways, but she is faced with more obstacles than she’d expected, and the choices she has to make about her new life have consequences she never could have anticipated.

I chose to read Second Nature because I’ve enjoyed Mitchard’s books in the past, and I was excited to find out that some characters from previous books (the Cappadora family, best known from The Deep End of the Ocean) make appearances in this book. The beginning of the book showed promise, and I found myself interested in Sicily’s story from the very start, but ultimately I felt that Mitchard crammed way too much drama into one novel here and was left feeling disappointed.

It is difficult to explain exactly what I didn’t love about this book without giving away plot spoilers, since my main issue had to do with the events in the book, so the best way that I can say it is this – just when I thought the events of the book had hit their breaking point of ridiculousness, something even MORE ridiculous would happen. I don’t mean ridiculous like stupid, I mean that there is NO possible way THIS many coincidences could happen, that this much stuff could happen to one person, etc. Does that make any sense?

However, I have to admit that I did care enough about the characters to continue reading through my disbelief and finish the book. I also am a fan of Mitchard’s writing and have enjoyed a few of her other novels in part because of the writing. She does write a compelling story with well-drawn characters.

I was sad not to like this one. It’s disappointing when an author you typically enjoy provides you with something less than stellar. Oh well.

9 thoughts on “Second Nature by Jacquelyn Mitchard”

  1. I actually liked the book…loved seeing the Capadoras again. But I definitely felt there was some awkwardness with all the relationship angst, and the dialogue was off. The biggest highlight for me was just all the face transplant stuff. I did some research though and the perfection of what happened in this book is just not the way it works. It is pretty amazing stuff, but a face transplant does not make the recipient something akin to a movie star.

    1. I completely agree about seeing the Cappadoras again. That’s interesting about your research, although not surprising in the least. I definitely felt that the face transplant stuff was glamorized quite a bit in the novel.

  2. I know just what you mean about too many coincidences ruining a book for you. It’s happened to me before, and from reading Sandy’s comment, I also have to agree that getting a face transplant doesn’t make you gorgeous. I don’t like it when there are so many unbelievable and coincidental elements to a story. I have a feeling that I wouldn’t like this one very much. Perhaps I should start with another Mitchard book…

    1. Yes, start with another Mitchard book! The Deep End of the Ocean is my favorite of the ones I’ve read. It was an Oprah pick YEARS back but don’t let that deter you. 🙂 It’s really good.

  3. I understand the disappointment of reading a book from an enjoyed author only to have it not quite meet expectations. This book was too much for me. I like simplicity. Too many twists will have readers twisting their brains, and we all know that’s a headache.

    Regardless, I do look forward to your next review.

    I have more.
    Regibald Inkling

  4. That is disappointing when you find you didn’t really care for the story after all. I’ve only read two of her books, both of which I enjoyed. The story sounds so compelling but your overall impression has me thinking that this is one not to pick up any time soon!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s