Review: Willing Spirits

Title:  Willing Spirits

Author:  Phyllis Schieber

Published:  reprint edition with Book Club guide inside — March 3, 2009

# of Pages:  292

ISBN:  978-0425225851

My Rating:  4.5/5

Both teachers, both in their forties, Jane Hoffman and Gwen Baker have a friendship that has helped them endure.  It was Jane who looked after Gwen when her husband left her to raise two young sons alone.  And when Jane comes home one day unexpectedly and finds her husband in a shameless act of betrayal, she immediately turns to Gwen for support.

Now, tested by additional personal crises, Jane and Gwen face new challenges – as mothers, as daughters, as women.  And in the process, they will learn unexpected truths about their friendship – and themselves.

I toured Schieber’s The Sinner’s Guide to Confession a few months ago and really enjoyed the book, so when I was offered the option of touring Willing Spirits too, I absolutely jumped at the chance.  Based on my first experience with Schieber I knew that I would enjoy this book, but it really surprised me just how much I ended up loving it.  I’d have to say I even liked it more than Sinner’s – and I really wasn’t expecting to.

Willing Spirits is completely a character-driven novel.  The book centers around two women, Jane and Gwen, best friends in their forties, both with adult children (well, college-age), and the major, and not so major, events that are occurring in their present-day lives.  Interspersed with what’s going on now, the two women slowly reveal to the reader snippets of their pasts, so that when the book is over the reader knows a LOT about these two women.  I mean, I really felt like I knew these women – better than I know some people in my real life even.

Both women are flawed but extremely likeable.  Both women have made mistakes in their lives, but they also have both dealt with some pretty hard things.  Nothing major, really – there is no suicide, drugs, eating disorders, cancer, losing children, etc. – none of the “issues” that you typically find in these kinds of books.  The story, rather, is about a bunch of little things that make up womens’ lives – the fact that how our parents raise us can really shape our marriages and our own parenting styles, the small decisions that we make that, together, can easily add up to an unfulfilled life, and the simple truth that a best friend can make all the difference in the world when dealing with all the little things life throws at you. 

The book really just spoke to me.  I think that’s the only way to put it.  I have almost zero in common with these women, on the surface, but I can see parts of myself in both of them.  And something about the way Schieber drew these characters and their relationships felt very authentic to me.  I really related to both Jane and Gwen, and I think that many women will see aspects of their own lives reflected in the ladies of Willing Spirits.

Willing Spirits was just re-released with a brand new cover (pretty, isn’t it?) and a book club guide in the back.  I think the book would be a fantastic choice for womens’ book clubs – tons of stuff to discuss, and I think almost all women will be able to relate to the book on some level.

Highly recommended.

More reviews –

18 thoughts on “Review: Willing Spirits”

  1. Heather: I am so glad that you enjoyed WILLING SPIRITS. You review is important because you make it clear that while you may have nothing in common with these women, you feel connected to them. That means a great deal to me. You are quite right. This is a character driven novel in which my hope is that readers will come to know Jane and Gwen with an intensity that might not be possible in a plot driven story. Based on your review, I feel that I accomplished my goal, and it is wonderful to know that. Thank you.

    1. Thank you so much for your kind words, Ms. Schieber! I’ve loved both of your books, and I’m honored to have had the opportunity to review them. Thanks so much – and good luck with future novels (which I sincerely hope you write!).

      1. Heather, please call me Phyllis. I have had an extraordinary time on each of my tours.Thanks for your good wishes. I am working on a new novel and hoping to finish this summer. You’ll be one of the first to hear about it!

  2. This does sound great. I love how it’s just about everyday life and not a major crisis that defines these women. I’m definitley going to check this out.

  3. It’s amazing how when they redo the cover it can really change people’s perception of the book at first glance! Your review was absolutely wonderful and I think that this is a book that I would enjoy!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s